Routes

Planner

Features

Updates

App

Login or Signup

Get the App

Login or Signup

Routes
Hiking trails & Routes
United States
New York
Westchester County

Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop

Moderate

3.1

(10)

58

hikers

Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop

02:22

8.53km

160m

Hiking

The Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop is a moderate hiking route spanning 5.3 miles (8.5 km) within the Rockefeller State Park Preserve. You will gain 511 feet (156 metres) in elevation over an estimated 2 hours and 22 minutes. This trail offers a quieter, more isolated experience compared to other…

Last updated: March 7, 2026

Waypoints

A

Start point

Parking

Get Directions

1

982 m

Bench with a View at Pasture Lane

Highlight • Viewpoint

This is a really nice spot to sit, relax and take in the wildlife.

Tip by

2

2.90 km

Buttermilk Hill USGS Benchmark

Highlight • Monument

This plaque from 1833 commemorates the 200th anniversary of the Buttermilk Hill triangulation station established by the US Geological Survey. This station is recognized as the oldest triangulation point in …

Tip by

3

3.86 km

Goat Trail

Highlight (Segment) • Trail

This is a nice section of trail, where you hike in between boulders and trees.

Tip by

B

8.53 km

End point

Parking

Loading

Way Types & Surfaces

Way Types

6.95 km

806 m

683 m

< 100 m

Surfaces

6.95 km

806 m

683 m

< 100 m

Sign up to see more specific route details

Sign up for free

Elevation

Elevation

Nothing selected – click and drag below to see the stats for a specific part of the route.

Highest point (200 m)

Lowest point (100 m)

Sign up to see more specific route details

Sign up for free

Weather

Powered by Foreca

Today

Monday 13 July

29°C

17°C

32 %

Additional weather tips

Max wind speed: 18.0 km/h

to get more detailed weather forecasts along your route

Comments

guide_signup

Want to know more?

Sign up for a free komoot account to join the conversation.

Sign up for free

This route was planned by komoot.

Save

Edit route

Download GPX

Move start point

Print

Share

Embed on a website

Report an Issue

Report restricted access

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it typically take to hike the Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop?

The Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop is approximately 8.5 kilometers (5.3 miles) long. Based on komoot's data, it typically takes around 2 hours and 22 minutes to complete this hike.

What is the difficulty level of this trail?

This trail is rated as moderate. While much of it follows wide, relatively level carriage roads, sections of the Buttermilk Hill Trail can be narrower and steeper, especially as it ascends and hugs rock outcroppings. The Goat Trail segment also involves hiking between boulders and trees, adding to the moderate challenge.

What is the terrain like on the Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop?

The terrain is varied. You'll encounter wide, relatively level dirt and gravel carriage roads, as well as narrower, steeper sections, particularly on the Buttermilk Hill portion. The route also includes walking through open fields and a unique segment on the Goat Trail where you'll navigate between boulders and trees.

Are there any notable viewpoints or landmarks along the route?

Yes, there are several points of interest. You can enjoy pleasant western views towards the Hudson River Palisades. The trail also passes by a Bench with a View at Pasture Lane and the historic Buttermilk Hill USGS Benchmark, which is the oldest triangulation point in America. Buttermilk Hill itself is the highest point in the Rockefeller State Park Preserve.

What is the best time of year to hike this loop?

Spring is an excellent time to visit, as you can enjoy abundant wildflowers and observe migratory songbirds, including colorful warblers. The wide carriage roads also make the trail accessible even with snow on the ground, offering a different experience in winter.

Is the Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop dog-friendly?

Yes, dogs are generally allowed in the Rockefeller State Park Preserve, but they must be kept on a leash at all times. Please ensure you clean up after your pet to help maintain the preserve's natural beauty.

Do I need a permit or is there an entrance fee for the Rockefeller State Park Preserve?

There are typically no entrance fees for hikers to access the trails within the Rockefeller State Park Preserve. However, there may be parking fees depending on the specific parking area and time of year. It's always a good idea to check the official Rockefeller State Park Preserve website for the most current information on parking and regulations before your visit.

Where can I park to access the Buttermilk Hill to Reservoir Loop?

The trail is located within the Rockefeller State Park Preserve in Pleasantville, NY. You can typically find parking at designated lots within the preserve. It's advisable to check the preserve's official website for specific parking locations and any potential fees or restrictions.

Does this trail intersect with other paths?

Yes, the route incorporates sections of several other trails. You will hike along parts of the Hudson Valley Greenway Trail (Elmsford to New Castle), the North County Trailway (both general and hiking sections), and significantly, the Goat Trail and the Buttermilk Hill Trail itself.

What is the historical significance of Buttermilk Hill?

Buttermilk Hill has a rich history. It is said to have received its name during the American Revolutionary War when local farmers hid their dairy cattle on the ridge. Additionally, the area features some of the earliest carriage roads, built by John D. Rockefeller's grandfather, adding a historical dimension to your hike.

Is the Buttermilk Hill area more secluded than other parts of the preserve?

Yes, the Buttermilk Hill area is often described as a lesser-visited and more isolated section of the Rockefeller State Park Preserve. This offers a quieter and more wild hiking experience compared to some of the more popular areas within the preserve.

Nearby routes

Moderate

4.8

79

Hook Mountain and Nyack Beach Loop

03:10h

10.8km

330m

Explore
RoutesRoute plannerFeaturesHikesMTB TrailsRoad cycling routesBikepackingSitemap
Download the app
Follow Us on Socials

© komoot GmbH

Privacy Policy