Sugarloaf Mountain Loop via Pecoy Notch and Mink Hollow Trails

The entire loop is approximately 10.2 km (6.3 miles) and generally takes around 4 hours and 5 minutes to complete. However, actual times can vary significantly based on your fitness level, trail conditions, and how much time you spend enjoying the views.

No, this loop is consistently rated as difficult or challenging. It includes sections of the infamous Devil's Path, known for its ruggedness, steep ascents, and rock scrambles. Hikers should be skilled and in good physical condition.

The primary access point for this loop is the Roaring Kill Trailhead. Parking is available there, but it can fill up quickly, especially on weekends. Arriving early is often recommended.

Expect diverse and challenging terrain. Sections of the Mink Hollow Trail follow old woods roads but can be very wet, rocky, and feel like hiking in a streambed. You'll encounter sustained steep climbs, some reaching grades of 30% or more, especially on the Devil's Path. There are numerous rock scrambles, and some areas require using hands and upper body strength to pull yourself up. Mud and wetness are common, particularly after rain.

The loop offers several scenic spots. On the Pecoy Notch Trail, you'll find Dibble's Quarry, which provides open views of Kaaterskill High Peak and parts of the Hudson River Valley. Further along, a former beaver pond offers views of Sugarloaf Mountain. The Mink Hollow Trail features a small waterfall and a dramatic view of Plateau Mountain. While the summit of Sugarloaf Mountain itself is treed-in, there are viewpoints along the Devil's Path Between Pecoy Notch Trail and Sugarloaf Mountain providing vistas of Twin Mountain and other surrounding areas, including the Sugarloaf Mountain Overlook.

The best time to hike is typically from late spring through early fall. The trail can be very wet and muddy in spring, and fall offers beautiful foliage. It is not recommended for winter due to extreme difficulty, icy conditions, and the potential need for technical mountaineering gear.

Yes, dogs are generally allowed on this trail. However, due to the extreme difficulty, steep rock scrambles, and rugged terrain, it may not be suitable for all dogs, especially smaller or less agile ones. Always keep your dog on a leash and be prepared for challenging conditions.

The Sugarloaf Mountain Loop is located within the Indian Head Wilderness. Currently, there are no specific permits or entrance fees required to hike this trail. However, always check the latest regulations from the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) before your visit, as rules can change.

Given the wet and rocky conditions, sturdy, non-waterproof hiking boots are often recommended, as waterproof ones might not dry quickly enough when submerged. Bringing extra socks is a good idea. Trekking poles can be helpful for stability on steep and uneven terrain. Always carry plenty of water, snacks, a map, compass or GPS, and appropriate layers for changing weather.

Many hikers prefer to do the loop counterclockwise, starting with the Mink Hollow Trail. This approach allows for a more gradual warm-up before tackling the demanding western side of Sugarloaf Mountain and reserves the scenic Pecoy Notch and Dibble's Quarry for the latter part of the hike. Some experienced hikers, however, prefer to tackle the most difficult sections first while their legs are fresh.

Yes, the route incorporates sections of several well-known paths. You will hike along portions of the Mink Hollow Trail, the Pecoy Notch Trail, and the famous Devil's Path. The Long Path also overlaps with parts of this loop.